Read More
Transgender individuals have called upon the government to reconsider the requirements for changing the gender marker on their ID cards, citing concerns about surgical mandates and privacy invasion.
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT
They argue that the current regulations, which mandate complete sex reassignment surgery, are overly restrictive.
The government recently announced that individuals who have not undergone full surgery can apply for a change of sex entry on their Hong Kong identity cards, but only if they meet several criteria.
For individuals seeking a change from female to male, the requirement is the removal of the breasts.
For those transitioning from male to female, the government stipulates the removal of both the penis and testes.
Also, applicants must make a statutory declaration confirming their gender dysphoria, provide evidence of having lived in their identified gender for over two years, and commit to continuing to live as such.
They must also demonstrate a minimum of two years of hormonal treatment, with ongoing treatment and submit blood test reports for hormonal profile verification.
Despite these policy changes, activists expressed disappointment.
Zephyrus Tsang Ling-yin, co-founder of Quarks - an organization supporting trans teens in Hong Kong - and a transgender man and doctor himself, have criticized the requirement for surgical treatment, questioned the definition of womanhood and hoped for the elimination of surgical obligations.
"What is a woman? Is that one called a woman without a penis? We hoped there would be no surgical requirements," Tsang said.
Tsang also expresses concern about the government's invasion of trans applicants' privacy by mandating a minimum two years of hormone treatment without specifying standardized hormone levels.
Anna, a trans woman and the community and resources manager at Quarks, said she has already undergone breast augmentation and facial feminization surgeries.
"The risk of undergoing such surgery is huge, as it involves the urinal system, which might possibly make us disabled and require help to go to the toilet," Anna said.
Anna hoped that the government will reduce the surgical requirements while "maintaining a threshold that distinguishes transgender individuals from cross-dressers."
Ming, co-founder of Quarks and a trans woman, argued the policy changes are discriminatory because they impose different surgical requirements for trans men and trans women.
Ming advocates for a relaxation of the threshold, allowing individuals to change their gender marker on their identity cards based solely on a declaration.

Anna














