Read More
A 27-year-old man was jailed for four months on Wednesday for illegally detaining an off-duty cop in public who was recording protesters at Prince Edward MTR station on his phone during the August 31 incident in 2019.
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT
The defendant Wat Kwan-pang, a sound technician, had earlier pleaded not guilty to false imprisonment but was convicted by magistrate Philip Chan Chee-fai at Kowloon City Court last month.
In sentencing, Chan said false imprisonment is a serious criminal offense and Wat should have known what behaviors will breach the law and shouldn’t use the social atmosphere of the time as an excuse.
Chan continued that Wat alongside other protesters stopped the off-duty cop from leaving the scene and forced that cop to delete photos and videos on his phone.
Although the cop was detained only for a few minutes, he was surrounded by an emotional crowd and had no other choice apart from deleting the photos and videos, otherwise his safety would have been endangered, Chan said.
Chan pointed to Wat’s high level of involvement as Wat pulled the cop back, patted his shoulder, and pointed at him, blocking his way when the cop was about to leave. Others cursed at the cop as well.
Chan also dismissed Wat’s statement that he thought the cop was about to harm others, saying if that was the case others would have filed a police report.
In mitigation, the defense referred to Wat’s background report that Wat only patted the cop’s shoulder and didn’t cause any physical injury to the cop. The lawyer also said Wat committed the crime out of impulse and showed remorse, adding he has a clean criminal record.
Still, Chan rejected the defense’s call for a community service order and jailed Wat for four months.
Another defendant – a 23-year-old student surnamed Leung – was earlier acquitted of the charge after Chan referred to footage where she didn’t ask the cop to delete his recordings and was trying to calm him down.
















