Read More
Night Recap - November 17, 2026
29 mins ago
Elon Musk warns Hong Kong risks fading away over ultra-low birth rate
16-11-2026 18:16 HKT




In cross-examining Chan Pui-man, the former associate publisher of Apple Daily, during Jimmy Lai Chee-ying's national security trial, the defense's leading counsel, Robert Pang Yiu-hung, argued that Lai's instruction to Chan for a press release from Benedict Rogers, the founder of Hong Kong Watch, to be published was merely a suggestion and not a direct order.
The defense presented chat records showing that Lai had forwarded a press release from Rogers to Chan, suggesting that she publish it.
The defense also showed WhatsApp chat records between Chan and then editorial writer Yeung Ching-kee, revealing that Lai wanted staff to get Sang Pu to write columns for Apple Daily.
However, Sang Pu ended up not contributing to the newspaper at all due to concerns about his pro-independence political stance, which were voiced by Yeung. When asked if Lai ever expressed support for Hong Kong independence, Chan admitted she had never heard him do so, not even during "lunch box meetings" at editorial meetings, but said also that she had never broached the issue with Lai.Chan also said she and other Apple Daily staff were shocked when their then boss kept his "Live Chat with Jimmy Lai" program going even after the national security law had come into effect.
Lai did not instruct her to do anything against the national security law, she said, but his live chat program and columns were published on Apple Daily's platforms without being edited or vetted by staff.The defense also inquired about an executive order signed by then US president Donald Trump on July 14, 2020, in response to the national security law coming into effect.
Lai had sent Chan an extract of the White House press release on the order as well as added some paragraphs about the idea of creating a sanctions list for individuals involved in censorship and intimidation.The defense suggested that Lai might have simply forwarded messages from others to her, but Chan objected to this characterization, saying that she found it odd that Lai had sent her the messages without explaining his intention.
She regarded it as an instruction from Lai to follow up on the sanctions list.The defense also presented a headline from an Apple Daily story on July 18, 2020, stating that Vice President Han Zheng, then SAR chief executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor and then commissioner of police Chris Tang Ping-keung were listed on a US sanctions list.
The defense claimed that both the list and the headline were attributed to an article by Bloomberg.