Read More
Congratulations! The government's pay-as-you-throw scheme was finally given the kick-start to give Easter Monday a special meaning.
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT
It is special because Hong Kong probably is still one of the very few - if not the only - developed economies where citizens remain oblivious to discarding household garbage in a way that is friendly to the environment.
However, the scheme that kicked off yesterday is a limited one covering just a handful of premises at 14 locations across the city, including public and private residential blocks, shopping malls and restaurants.
It may sound impressive to include an entire public estate but the Lin Tsui Estate in Chai Wan, for example, is just a single-block estate.
Would it be more persuasive to include more premises in this phase of trial along with bigger estates? That would make the experience more useful for reference.
It has taken the administration longer than expected to set in motion a program comparable to the standards of many developed economies.
Originally slated to commence by year-end 2023 after the scheme was approved by the legislature in 2021, it was postponed to April this year before it was further deferred to August.
Under the charge scheme, families are required to pay 11 cents for every liter of garbage thrown away and residents must buy designated plastic bags available in different sizes from three to 100 liters.
Households and businesses participating in the trial that commenced yesterday are given the bags for free.
It is hoped that the trial will offer Secretary for Environment and Ecology Tse Chin-wan the information he is expecting so that his office can clear any remaining concerns society may still have about the new plastic bag charges.
Tse's earlier announcement to postpone the pay-as-you-throw scheme for the second time generated speculation that the government might be looking to shelve the initiative in the wake of public criticism over the way families are expected to buy these bags to put their unwanted items in and for management companies to put them in even bigger bags for the landfills.
Officials are aware that, if they ended up scrapping the initiative, it would cast doubts on their governance.
It is unlikely that the administration is making use of the trial to back down from the scheme which, despite the controversies over recent weeks, should be the least controversial in principle.
Rather, officials are believed to be keen to see the scheme press ahead ,whether for the sake of governance or for the environment.
To make the scheme more acceptable to the public, it will be vital to make it as simple as possible.
People are concerned because they face the threat of a HK$1,500 fine if they are found to have dumped garbage in bags not designated by the government.
Government contractors manufacturing the bags are certainly happy to see the program launch.
However, people genuinely concerned about the environment are also keen to see no more delay for the program that has already been deferred twice.














