Read More
The cultural chief has put forward a rather eye-opening suggestion.Also, in order to clear the way for the "new" Science Museum tenant to move in, the Heritage Museum will have to vacate to nowhere in particular, with exhibits scattered around in different museums and similar facilities.
To equip the SAR with a museum dedicated to showcasing China's achievements, Kevin Yeung Yun-hung is proposing to relocate the popular Science Museum to the current site of the Heritage Museum in Sha Tin to make way for the new museum to move in to its existing site in Tsim Sha Tsui.
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT
It is truly an amusing idea to complicate a project that, budget allowing, could have been simple and straight forward to deliver.
The reasons that Yeung's bureau has referred to in a document for lawmakers concern logistics.
First, the location of the new museum has to be readily accessible in the city center. Second, among others, converting an existing facility to house the new museum would shorten the time as it may take longer to build one from scratch.
These are valid factors that budget-savvy officials are expected to consider in the planning process - but they are not the only major factors.One of the major drawbacks is that it would create other problems which would have to be tackled simultaneously or, preferably, beforehand.
Yeung made no mention of money, so can it be assumed that budget is not a concern?If money was never a concern, the government should simply build a new museum in the harbor-facing open space near Tamar, the headquarters of the PLA's Hong Kong garrison, or alongside the Hong Kong Palace Museum in West Kowloon.
In view of the city's vast experience in building museums, it should not be difficult to finish the project faster than the Hong Kong Palace Museum.However, is money really not a concern? To be fair to Yeung, he may be trying to be money-wise.
It is the first time that Hong Kong is to acquire a major museum to showcase the country's success and the history of the Chinese Communist Party.In the absence of a direct comparison, the Hong Kong Palace Museum in West Kowloon may offer the nearest reference.
It cost HK$3.5 billion to build, with the Hong Kong Jockey Club footing the bill - and the future museum of national achievements will have to be no less grand in scale if it is to truly demonstrate the country's pride.After considering inflation, the cost of building such a facility from scratch - even on an available site in Central or West Kowloon - would likely exceed that of the Palace Museum.
Would the Jockey Club still be able to bear the cost of such a grand-scale project after having been asked by the financial secretary to contribute billions more to the government each year?Yeung must have estimates for the various options that have been considered by his team even though the Legco paper made no reference to the finance.
It is probable that the current proposal would cost taxpayers the least.Perhaps Yeung should reveal the dollar terms when Legco meets on Monday as he explains his case.
Kevin Yeung














