Read More
The fuss over the recognition of the Diploma of Secondary Education following the replacement of Liberal Studies by the new subject of Citizenship and Social Development appears to be fading quickly after a week of confusion.
ADVERTISEMENT
SCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT
After 45 universities - including top institutions like Yale in the US, Cambridge in the UK and Sydney in Australia - heeded the Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority's appeal and updated their entry requirements in the past week, the number of universities yet to update their requirements dropped from 79 to 34 as of this week.
The number will continue to change as more universities reply to HKEEA.
The incident - which, in hindsight, was little more than a fuss - erupted after lawmaker and Federation of Education Workers vice-chairman Tang Fei hit the alarm button in the Legislative Council in the middle of last week.
Tang surprised everyone in Legco - as well as every parent with children of school age - declaring that 77 overseas universities, including the most famous ones, failed to appear in the HKEEA's website page that contains a list of overseas universities accepting applications using DSE results.
Tang, an educator by profession, was being less than cautious. His assertion in Legco that he was uncertain whether or not these higher institutes were no longer recognizing the DSE was not a question. Rather, it was like a statement from the former school principal.
Wasting no time, the media quickly conducted a count and found 79 were indeed missing - two more than mentioned by Tang.
A question is: did the lawmaker, returned from the Election Committee constituency, try to communicate with Secretary for Education Christine Choi Yuk-lin to voice his grave concern to clarify it rather than waiting to make such a major revelation in the Legco session?
Given the swift development as the city was enveloped by outcries and parents consumed by fears over the incident, Choi or her subordinates at the Education Bureau should have been able to answer Tang's concern prior to the Legco meeting.
There are several lessons to learn from the fiasco.
First and foremost, although lawmakers these days are elected by an exercise that is less competitive than before, they are also expected to do their homework to equip themselves with the basics before attending a meeting.
In the DSE fiasco, Tang did half of the homework expected. While he was diligent enough to go through the lengthy list and spotted 77 missing names (though it was later found to be 79), the lawmaker seemingly opted to raise a huge alarm that, in hindsight, was much ado about nothing.
Many YouTubers fell into the trap too.
Then, there are the parents. Having been anxious for a full week, they have learned that what was guaranteed before can change in the future.
Parents are never willing to take a chance when it concerns their children's interest.
After this "crisis," it is likely that parents who are in a position to do so will start making Plan B as an insurance for their children just in case something untoward happens, as with this recent fuss.
Politicians may want to make noise, but it should not be noise of this kind.














