|


Father Fernando, aged 70, is more comfortable
speaking Indonesian or his native Italian, rather than English. A resident of
Aceh for almost two decades, he runs the Catholic church and adjacent school,
serving a flock of mainly Chinese-Indonesians.
His twinkling eyes and shaggy white hair are a testament to his survival skills.
As usual on a Christmas Day, he had celebrated mass in central Banda Aceh then
taken a bus down the west coast to Meulaboh.
There, in a town since made famous by disaster, he held a Christmas mass. The
next morning, as he was at the bus station ready to go back to Banda Aceh, he
heard the people shouting in panic. With everyone else, the priest ran away
from the coast trying to escape the tsunami, but he couldn't run fast enough.
He took refuge in one of the few buildings left standing: on the second floor of
a mosque.
It was a fitting place. ``Yes of course, why not! I have also been giving refuge
to Muslims for many years,'' he says, in reference to his church's program of
importing foreign doctors to operate on Muslim children with cleft palates
along Aceh's north coast.
``I spent four days in Meulaboh,'' recounts the priest, ``moving from one house
to another. First we stayed in an Acehnese house, then in a Chinese house, then
in a school with many policemen.'' He slept under a peasant house, with
soldiers, so close to a chicken coop he feared getting bird flu, he jokes.
His odyssey reveals the tolerant and cosmopolitan aspects of life atop Aceh's
Islamic bedrock. This is where Islam first came to Indonesia half a millenium
ago - and it has generally been confident, erudite Islam rather than its
paranoid, more radical cousin.
Even in the midst of what Father Fernando calls ``an apocalyptic vision'' of
destruction, the ties that bound humanity were stronger than those that
divided.
But some Indonesians and aid workers worry that the need to let Acehnese think
for themselves may be lost in the enormous aid push underway, some of it by
ambitious religious groups with agendas that go beyond shelter and food.
One United States Agency for International Development (USAID) official says
it's the perfect opportunity for aid groups - faith-based or not - to make
funding proposals based around the tsunami. ``Even in the first week we saw a
flood of proposals, with high expat salaries, the works. This disaster will
make careers,'' she says. A key goal early on was to get USAID stickers on to
every shipment to make sure the publicity was clear. Some staff have been seen
giving autographs.
For many groups pouring into Aceh, it's not only a time to harvest the big bucks
of aid flowing in, but to harvest souls.
Veteran aid workers say they are not surprised by the onslaught of unusual
groups appearing at the scene of disaster, but fear their impact.
``It's the first time I've run into so many different people from so many
different agencies in one place,'' says Wayne Ulrich, emergency coordinator for
Catholic Relief Services, a non-evangelical, pragmatic aid organisation.
Many long-term aid agencies might have roots in a particular faith but have
decades of experience and they work irrespective of others' race, creed or
religion. These ecumenical churches offer broad acceptance of varied faiths and
aim their good works at a multicultural world.
Some groups are widely seen as cults, pushing a quasi-religious doctrine of
healing and feeling. Other groups, particularly American evangelicals
associated with the conservative politics of the Bush administration, focus on
a personal and direct relationship with a defined God through literal adherence
to ancient texts. Their temptation, say critics, is to use disaster as an
excuse to make converts.
``There are elements here which shouldn't be here,'' says the director of one of
the largest international aid agencies working in Aceh. ``There are lots of
faith-based groups, and some of them are explicit about the need to spread the
word. People will get sick of that pretty quick.''
In a city famed for its gracious mosque, built according to an Italian design
with Dutch money in 1881, still standing alongside colonial and Chinese
buildings, a rich history has survived the tsunami. But it has yet to weather
the spiritual after-shocks.
Directly across from the Pendopo, the old Dutch Governor's House in Banda Aceh
built in 1880, is a cluster of large green tents with foreigners sitting around
in bright yellow T-shirts. The logo: ``Church of Scientology.''
``We're focusing on emotional stress and trauma,'' says Gregory Churilov, an
Argentinian convert to the cult which promises new life for hard cash.
``Here, it's as if everyone's been in a huge car accident, whole families have
been wiped out, and Scientology offers a methodology to handle loss and
trauma.''
He disclaims any intention to garner converts: ``We really frown on that. You
can look at all this in two ways: that we are getting more exposure because we
are greedy for converts, or that we are getting more exposure because we are
willing to help.''
He and his cohorts are offering the so-called science of ``Dianetics,'' a
cathartic form of therapy which includes a form of massage ``to get the person
in communication with their body.'' Churilov claims to have mastered a ``basic
technique to orient people into the present, to snap them out of the past,
making them more alert.''
But one group of men gathered around a cooking fire at the university's mosque
were merely bemused, feeling no need for massage, they said, and having no idea
what Scientology might be.
In an unusual twist on the notion of bringing aid to the destitute, Churilov
says his group arrived in Aceh with nothing and were given tents by the army
and food by friendly locals. Unfazed that the aid flow was meant to go the
other way, he used this as an example of how well accepted the Scientologists
were by the local people, rather than an example of traditional manners.
But the notion that catching people in a weakened state and exposing them to
ideas and practices they have never felt the need for before is disturbing.
``I was at a meeting and I was surprised at how many groups there were saying
they were into psycho-social and trauma recovery, and we've never heard of them
before,'' says Indonesian psychologist and London graduate Livia Iskandar. She
helps run a group called Pulih (literally To Recover), of professional trauma
experts who focus on the need for community-based solutions to conflict or
disaster.
``There is a danger of pathologizing people and not giving time for normal
recovery to take place. This is a collective trauma - it's too early to label
individuals as traumatized.
``We know the Acehnese are very strong people. Aceh has special characteristics
in its culture and religion that even as Indonesians, we need to be aware of.
We really appreciate efforts by the international community, but there is a
need to respect the traditions already in place,'' she says.
Radical Islamic groups have received the most attention so far, but aid workers
at established agencies also wonder what Christian evangelists, including
Mormons, on the streets of Banda Aceh might have to offer.
A strange confluence of need and available money has also drawn groups focused
on, say, the trafficking of women, which has rarely been an issue in cohesive
Acehnese society.
``We're having money thrown at us by the United States government for
trafficking programs we haven't even asked for!'' says a communications
director of a large international agency.
One faith-based group intent on saving women from prostitution, whether they
like it or not, is the International Justice Mission (IJM), a group of
God-fearing, Harvard-trained lawyers. Describing itself as a
``Christ-centered'' organization on its Web site, it argues - and provides
biblical references for - a doctrine of ``explicitly Christian'' direct
intervention.
IJM's Sean Litton, speaking on the phone from Medan wouldn't talk about what he
was doing in Sumatra and refers callers to his US head office. ``We're in the
middle of things it would not be a good thing to talk about,'' he says.
Drew Bishop of Compassion International is more open and admits that its current
work with local partner, PESAT, is a departure from its usual business of
training local churches in child development.
``We are channeling funds through local partners and providing a framework for
the many volunteers coming in who have no idea what they're doing,'' says
Bishop.
``We had looked to contact Christians in Aceh but found most of the churches
were filled with bodies. We're still looking, we want to get them involved.
``We want to distance ourselves from Christian groups who are trying to assign
blame or judgment. We are here just because we care. We're not asking if
recipients are Christian or not. We're saying we can help you to help your own
people.''
Hans Geni, of PESAT, is an Indonesian Pentecostal Christian but insists his
kindergartens all over Indonesia follow the national, not a sectarian,
curriculum. The tsunami has given his group an opportunity to enter Aceh for
the first time.
It's a different faith but a similar message over at the office of the World
Association of Muslim Youth. Hamid Sa-ad from Jeddah has an ``open budget'' and
is overseeing the work of loading piles of food and household kits on to trucks
for distribution to camps.
``We have some Islamic programs in education, to explain what Islam is to
non-Muslim people. But in Indonesia there is no need for this,'' he says.
But right next door is the office of a group which aided the rampaging
Indonesian military-backed militias in East Timor in 1999. Young men lounging
at the offices of the Laskar Merah Putih say they're defenders of Indonesian
national unity.
``We are friends with the TNI [Indonesian Armed Forces],'' boasts Eddie
Juliansyah, an Acehnese who helps run the Laskar Merah Putih office.
More recent Islamic entrants include the Front Pembela Islam (FPI), better known
for trashing bars and other houses of sin in Jakarta, but now earning plaudits
for their volunteer work in collecting Aceh's corpses for proper burial.
Camped out in the Heroes Cemetery on the same street as the expanding Unicef
office in Banda Aceh, FPI leaders tried to expel two female reporters who
refused to wear headscarves. ``This is an Islamic state,'' they insisted,
although Acehnese Muslims rarely insist on such dogma.
Ploughing through the well-funded buffet of groups and ideas now on offer to the
Acehnese in this vulnerable time of their lives, it's easy to reach overload.
That's why the non-evangelical, mainstream Indonesian Council of Churches,
related to the liberal World Council of Churches in Geneva, has a special
taskforce to track just what Christian groups are doing.
``We are sharing information about the activities of all these groups,'' says
Frans Tumiwa, a leader of the Council of Churches. He and his colleagues worry
that many conservative Christian groups are giving the rest of the church a bad
name.
``The people in Aceh need to be helped, with practical things, with food and
supplies. But when people come in saying they're representing this or that
Christian group, well, there shouldn't be any talk about religion. Some of
these groups can destroy the whole image of the church,'' he says. He too
worries about the number of groups he's never heard of before, charging into
Aceh with many thousands of dollars and an explicit evangelical agenda.
``They give a wrong impression about the real mission of the church, which is to
be in solidarity with the people of Aceh,'' he says.
Samaritan's Purse is promising an airlift of a helicopter with crucial supplies.
This group is run by Franklin Graham, son of evangelist Billy Graham, and is
overt about catering to the spiritual as well as the physical needs of victims
of the tsunami.
Its Web site offers special prayers with biblical references to help make a
difference for the tsunami survivors, promising to meet the needs of victims
``with the purpose of sharing God's love through His Son, Jesus Christ.''
Just as conversion efforts by radical Islamists have long been rebuffed in Aceh,
so too has any other evangelism.
But the Samaritan's Purse promises to ``offer more than help. We offer hope. To
suffering people in a broken world, we share the news of the only One who can
bring true peace - Jesus Christ, Prince of Peace.''
World Relief is another one to watch. One veteran aid agency director recalled
seeing World Relief on the Thai-Cambodian border years ago, filling ox-carts
with bibles for Cambodians just emerging from the traumatic years of Khmer
Rouge rule.
``The bibles became strangely popular and it took us a while to work out why,
but it was because the paper they were printed on was such good quality that it
could be re-used as cigarette paper. It burned very nicely,'' the agency
director says.
Dr Galen Carey directs World Relief's work in Indonesia and insists he wouldn't
dream of sending bibles into Aceh as it would be ``too sensitive.'' He says his
work focuses on health, education, agriculture, refugees and trade.
Up to 20 percent of World Relief's funds come from churches, he says, some from
private donations, and about half from USAID.
``This is not a time to take advantage of people. What we are explaining is that
this is a time of tragedy, it's a time to provide help on a human to human
basis,'' Carey says.
``We have no plans to bring in bibles in or any other literature. I can't speak
for what has happened before.''
Meanwhile, the Taiwanese Buddhist group, the Tzu Chi Foundation, is bringing in
tents and building homes for thousands of displaced people regardless of faith.
``We don't get involved in politics. We have Muslim, Christian and Buddhist
volunteers,'' says Ji Shou, a Malaysian staffer with Tzu Chi.
|