|

A senior partner in a law firm is claiming almost
HK$20 million in damages for psychological injuries after his Shiitsu dog was
mauled to death by two mongrels owned by his former neighbors in Sai Kung.
Eugene Oh, senior partner of solicitors Eugene Oh and Co, and his wife Grace
Chin have both been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder, a
psychological disease more commonly associated with soldiers exposed to extreme
conflict, since the death of ``Sha Sha'' in summer of 2000.
His dog was fatally mauled by the two dogs of his former neighbours.
Oh also suffers from coronary heart disease which medical experts say is being
affected by his extreme mental condition, Senior Counsel Ruy Barretto told the
High Court Monday.
Oh's status as an experienced legal practitioner with a high regard for the law
further affected his mental condition after realizing that the dogs would go
unpunished for the killing of his beloved pet, his counsel said.
``A dog has special attributes - it has loyalty, returns affection and provides
companionship and comfort,'' Barretto said.
Deputy High Court judge Ian Carlson heard on Monday that Oh and his wife were
subjected to ``harmful reminders'' of the incident and feared further attacks
by the mongrels on their children because the defendants failed to improve
control of their dogs.
Barretto claims the neighbors' dogs had become more aggressive because of their
``victory'' over the Shiitsu and their enhanced perception of themselves as
lords of their territory.
The Shiitsu was dragged through the bars of a gate and bitten to death by the
dogs after it had wondered into the defendants' property while it was having a
walk with Chin.
A neighbor had to break into the property armed with a spade in order to recover
the fatally wounded dog.
Oh was notified by phone and reconstructed the events in his head after seeing
bloodstains around the neighborhood.
Barretto told the court that the imagination can often be worse than reality.
The fact that Oh was convicted in 2002 for common assault and criminal damage
for throwing rocks at the mongrels was already a symptom of the ``downward
spiral'' in his mental condition, said the counsel.
Defendants Yan Su-zher and his wife Kate Richdale claim they have the right to
protect their own premises, especially after they had found illegal immigrants
trespassing in the past.
Both parties have since moved from Clear Water Bay Road in Sai Kung. The hearing
continues today and is scheduled to last another week.
staff.reporter@singtaonewscorp.com
|