|

Hong Kong is losing out to the mainland because
of a decline in English standards in recent years, former chief secretary for
administration Anson Chan said.
``We are told often by businessmen who have businesses in Shanghai how much
better English is spoken in Shanghai than Hong Kong,'' Chan said Tuesday.
``It is a pity because we used to lead all the cities in mainland China. We need
to do all we can to retain, and sharpen this competitive edge or run the risk
of being overtaken by other cities in the mainland where the enthusiasm to
learn the language is growing very rapidly.
``English is not a colonial language to be shed after the handover, it is a
universal language that is spoken by probably more people in the world than any
other language.''
``
Chan spoke at the launch of English Adventure, a joint educational program
sponsored by the British Council and Prudential Insurance.
Her comments come ahead of a public consultation on a review of the
controversial Medium of Instruction (MOI) policy, expected to be launched by
the Education and Manpower Bureau (EMB) next month.
Chan said there are several steps that can be taken to reverse the decline. It
would be unfair, she said, to lay the blame entirely at the door of the
administration.
``The government has taken steps to put more resources to get teachers properly
trained in the teaching of the language. I hope that very soon we will see a
significant increase in the standard,'' she said.
Some experts say the EMB needs to overhaul the way English language is taught in
the territory's schools.
In an interview with The Standard Anita Poon, assistant professor at Hong
Kong Baptist University's department of education studies, criticized the EMB's
Native-speaker English Teacher Scheme (Nets), in which native speakers teach
English in schools.
Poon said that schools are not provided with sufficient guidance by the
department on the appropriate use of language teachers, and that it will be
more effective to focus Nets at the primary level than in secondary schools.
A spokeswoman for the EMB said that the Nets program was introduced in primary
schools in 2002.
Meanwhile, Chan said more can be done by the government.
``The government should set a good example and make sure we are truly bilingual,
which means that senior officials should speak in both languages,'' Chan said.
Teachers, students and the private sector also need to do their bit to prevent
standards from falling.
``It is important that teachers realize that they need to upgrade their
skills,'' said Chan.
She said that while quite a few of Hong Kong teachers are qualified to teach in
English, others clearly are not.
Ultimately, however, it is up to students.
``At the moment a lot of students do not seem to think that it is in their own
interest to learn English. [We need] to get over that hurdle,'' Chan said.
However, she said she does not consider that the current MOI policy was at fault
for the declining standards, saying that the when the policy was originally
introduced (in 1998) it was an acknowledgement of the fact that a lot of
schools that purported to teach in the English language were not qualified nor
equipped to do so.
``There is not much point in choosing English as the medium of instruction if
your teachers are not suitably trained and equipped to teach in that
language,'' Chan said.
She said the wider community can also help maintain and build English language
competencies.
``Businesses, enterprises, and academic institutions benefit from im-proved
English skills, so it is fitting that they should give something back to the
community by pitching in to help, not just by contributing the necessary funds,
but more importantly, sharing their resources and their expertise,'' Chan
added.
colum.murphy@globalchina.com
|