|

As inequality in Hong Kong rises to levels more
typically seen in Latin America than East Asia, government insiders say that
tackling poverty will be a key theme of Chief Executive Tung Chee-hwa's annual
policy address on Wednesday.
To address increasing public concern about poverty, Tung is expected to
establish a high-level committee to look into the city's growing poverty
levels. As a start, the committee will try to measure poverty by establishing a
minimum poverty line, something that the administration has refused to do.
Although Hong Kong's unemployment rate fell to 6.7 percent from 8 percent early
last year, there are still more the 200,000 out of work, according to
government figures.
Social welfare organizations say the gap between rich and poor has reached an
alarming level in Hong Kong. Unionist and Legislative Council member Lee
Cheuk-yan claims that the number of those living below the poverty line grew
from just over 900,000 in 1991 to nearly 1.3 million in 2001. The Society for
Community Organization (Soco), a social welfare concern group, says there are
some 350,000 children living under the poverty line: about one-third of all
Hong Kong's children. People earning less than HK$4,000 a month are living
below the poverty line, according to non-governmental organizations like Soco.
Cuts in welfare payments over the past two years have galvanized anti-poverty
groups. For a government that is petrified of public protests, that may be
reason enough to act. An improving fiscal situation may also allow more room
for maneuver.
Hong Kong's lowest paid workers have been working longer hours for steadily
declining wages - by as much as 20 per cent, according to the government's own
figures - since the handover. But, in October last year, the Liberal Party shot
down a Legislative Council motion which called on the government to set a
minimum wage and maximum working hours.
Despite the absence of an official poverty line, there's little question that
inequality is rising. One of the best-known measures of income inequality is
the Gini coefficient.
The Gini coefficient is a number between 0 and 1, where 0 corresponds with
perfect equality (where everyone has the same income) and 1 corresponds with
perfect inequality (where one person has all the income, and everyone else has
zero income).
In its Human Development Report 2003, the United Nations calculated that Hong
Kong's Gini coefficient rose sharply from 0.476 in 1991 to 0.525 in 2001.
This can hardly be a source of pride for Hong Kong.
It was the third-highest figure in the world, barely trailing developing
countries Central African Republic and Honduras.
Hong Kong's figure far exceeds those of other developed countries like
Singapore (0.45), the United States (0.35) and Japan (0.25).
Tung acknowledged in his policy address last year that ``globalization has
aggravated poverty generally in many places around the world and we are no
exception.''
He pledged to ``further examine how to help the poor elevate themselves, and to
improve their economic situation through sharing the opportunities that arise
from social development.''
As of September 2004 the total number of Comprehensive Social Security Allowance
(CSSA) recipients stood at 534,217, the highest ever. This represents a
three-fold increase from 1994.
As 2004 came to a close, Tung told media executives that his 2005 policy address
would announce a new anti-poverty committee to draft poverty relief measures.
The first task of the committee will be to establish a poverty line in Hong
Kong, giving both authorities and community organizations an objective
benchmark by which to measure performance and establish policy.
It is not hard to find examples of policy failure under the Tung
administration, but perhaps the worst, if not best known, is the growing number
of children living in poverty.
A Soco survey released in September last year found that about 350,000 children,
a quarter of all Hong Kong children, live in poverty.
Social Welfare Department statistics show that the number of children in
families receiving CSSA has risen six times in the past decade: from 20,900 in
1993 to 145,200 in July 2003.
The department said this accounted for 11 per cent of all children in the
territory in 2003.
As current government assistance merely covers school fees, the families of poor
children are unable to afford additional educational necessities such as
textbooks, bus tickets, computers, or to simply join extra-curricular
activities in their spare time.
Despite the generally improving economy, the government has slashed welfare
spending by 3.2 percent and funding to NGOs by 2.5 per cent in the current
fiscal year.
Meanwhile, Hong Kong's economy has rarely looked healthier.
Accounting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers has estimated that surging land sales
revenue and a general economic recovery could ease the fiscal pressure on the
government.
michael.ng@globalchina.com
|